If you’ve spent even five minutes scrolling through a Virgin River fan forum or diving into the chaos of Twitter (sorry, X), you’ve probably seen the same two names dominating the “most annoying” list —
Charmaine Roberts and Hope McCrea. Both women have sparked countless memes, debates, and rants, from Charmaine’s endless drama to Hope’s meddling ways. But lately,
something surprising has happened in the Virgin River fandom: fans have found new targets for their collective frustration.
Yes, you heard that right — as much as Charmaine’s mood swings or Hope’s bossiness can drive viewers up the wall, there are other characters who have managed to irritate fans even more. Whether it’s bad decisions, repetitive storylines, or just plain frustrating behavior, these five names have officially dethroned the usual suspects in Virgin River’s “most hated” club.
So, who are the true offenders? Let’s dig into the top five characters that make fans hit pause, roll their eyes, or yell at the TV — and why they’ve become the lightning rods of fan outrage.
1. Brie Sheridan – The Queen of Drama
When Brie Sheridan first arrived in Virgin River, she was supposed to be a breath of fresh air — strong, confident, and ready to shake things up. Instead, many fans now see her as the embodiment of unnecessary drama.
Why fans can’t stand her:
Brie’s impulsive decisions often leave a trail of chaos behind her. Her romantic entanglements have been criticized for feeling overly melodramatic, with some saying her storylines belong more in a daytime soap than in the gentle, emotional world of Virgin River. Viewers have also expressed frustration that her trauma arcs, while important, sometimes feel underdeveloped or exploited rather than sensitively portrayed.
Despite actress Zibby Allen’s strong performance, Brie’s character frequently feels “out of sync” with the show’s cozy, small-town rhythm. Fans appreciate her moments of vulnerability but wish the writers would give her more depth instead of constant turmoil.
In short, Brie isn’t hated because she’s bad — she’s hated because she could be so much better.
2. Dan Brady – The Bad Boy Who Won’t Grow Up
Ah, Dan Brady — the perpetual “bad boy with a good heart” who somehow keeps tripping over his own redemption arc. Once seen as a misunderstood rebel, Brady has tested even his most loyal defenders with his inability to learn from his mistakes.
Why fans can’t stand him:
Brady’s character seems trapped in a frustrating loop: he wants to be better, but his choices repeatedly drag him back into trouble. One episode he’s redeemable, the next he’s reckless again. His moral compass appears to shift depending on the plot, leaving viewers unsure whether they should root for him or give up entirely.
Many fans argue that Brady’s storyline feels repetitive and stagnant. Without real character growth, his “bad boy charm” has lost its spark — and the audience is ready for him to either turn things around or face the consequences.
3. Lizzie – The Teenage Tornado
When Lizzie first breezed into Virgin River, she was meant to inject youthful energy and a bit of chaos into the town’s calm routine. But for many viewers, that “chaos” quickly turned into constant frustration.
Why fans can’t stand her:
Lizzie is, in a word, exhausting. Her rebellious antics, impulsive behavior, and self-centered decisions make her hard to root for. Her relationship with Ricky, once a sweet young love story, turned into a saga of immaturity and miscommunication that had fans collectively groaning.
While some defend her as “a teenager just being a teenager,” others argue that her drama overshadows more interesting storylines. In online discussions, she’s often compared to a TikTok trend that just won’t die — loud, flashy, and impossible to ignore.
4. Calvin – The Villain Who Overstayed His Welcome
Every show needs a villain, and in Virgin River, that role belongs to Calvin — the local drug kingpin whose menacing presence adds an edge to the series. But as time goes on, many fans are wondering if that edge has dulled.
Why fans can’t stand him:
Calvin’s appearances feel increasingly random, serving more as a plot device than a believable antagonist. His character rarely evolves, his motives remain vague, and his criminal activities sometimes feel disconnected from the show’s heartwarming tone.
While some appreciate the tension he brings, others feel his storylines are predictable and overused. In a show built on love, healing, and community, Calvin often feels like a leftover piece from another genre entirely — one that keeps intruding on Virgin River’s charm.
5. Muriel St. Claire – The Perpetual Scene-Stealer
Muriel might not be a villain or a drama magnet, but she’s managed to irritate fans for a different reason: no one really knows why she’s still here.
Why fans can’t stand her:
Muriel has a knack for inserting herself into every possible situation, whether she’s needed or not. Her witty banter often lands flat, and many fans say her presence feels more like filler than function.
While some appreciate her as comic relief or a source of small-town flavor, others argue she adds little to the overall narrative. In fan discussions, Muriel is often described as that one neighbor who shows up uninvited — not mean-spirited, just… unnecessary.
Why Charmaine and Hope Get a Pass (This Time)
Don’t get it twisted — Charmaine Roberts and Hope McCrea are still among the most polarizing figures in Virgin River. But compared to the five names above, they’ve actually experienced moments of growth and redemption.
Charmaine, despite her dramatic pregnancy saga, has begun to show vulnerability and complexity that make her more relatable. Hope, for all her meddling and sharp tongue, often means well — her humor and no-nonsense attitude add much-needed levity to the show.
They’re flawed, yes, but they also feel integral to Virgin River’s DNA.
The “Love to Hate” Factor
Here’s the irony: the characters fans claim to hate are often the ones who keep the show alive. Virgin River thrives on tension, conflict, and emotional highs and lows. Without the occasional villain, troublemaker, or drama queen, the show might risk becoming too picture-perfect.
Think of these characters like seasoning — too much can ruin the dish, but without them, the flavor fades. The love-hate relationship fans have with Brie, Brady, Lizzie, Calvin, and Muriel is part of what makes the series so bingeable.
Fan Reactions: The Internet Speaks
A quick glance at Virgin River Reddit threads or TikTok edits reveals just how passionately fans feel. There are entire debates over whether Brie or Brady is more frustrating, memes poking fun at Muriel’s “magical ability to appear everywhere,” and even essays defending Lizzie’s right to teenage rebellion.
These conversations might be chaotic, but they also prove one thing — Virgin River fans care deeply about the characters, even when they’re annoyed by them.
Can These Characters Redeem Themselves?
That’s the million-dollar question. Could Brady finally turn his life around? Could Lizzie mature into a grounded young woman? Could Brie find peace without constant chaos? Virgin River has a history of surprising fans, so redemption arcs aren’t off the table.
Until then, viewers will continue their passionate debates, eye rolls, and love-hate relationships — because for every character that drives fans crazy, there’s another who keeps them coming back.
Final Thoughts
Charmaine and Hope may forever hold their spots in the Virgin River Hall of Frustration, but this season, they’ve officially been outdone. Brie, Brady, Lizzie, Calvin, and Muriel now carry the torch of fan annoyance — yet ironically, they also keep the series dynamic, unpredictable, and alive.
Love them or hate them, these five are proof that in Virgin River, perfection is boring, flaws are fascinating, and drama is absolutely essential. After all, if everyone behaved perfectly in this sleepy little town, what would we even watch?
